You will need the Flash plugin to view this publication
Download the Flash plugin for free here. Just refresh this page after installing Flash.
Also make sure that javascript is enabled in your browser.
Alternatively, you can download this publication in PDF-format - Click here.
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5
Page 6
Page 7
Page 8
Page 9
Page 10
Page 11
Page 12
Page 13
Page 14
Page 15
Page 16
Page 17
Page 18
Page 19
Page 20
Page 21
Page 22
Page 23
Page 24
Page 25
Page 26
Page 27
Page 28
Page 29
Page 30
Page 31
Page 32
Page 33
Page 34
Page 35
Page 36
MagazineCanadaPostPublicationsAgreementNumber40609661FallWinter2013TheofcialmagazineotheCanadianAssociationoDivingContractorsCADCInsIdeThsowMutGoOWitrdivigiCaaaUigsoarforUmadivigIpctioPartIILookBforYouLapHazarItificatioaRikAmt
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors3
4www.cadc.caFallWinter2013
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors5CADCMagazinePublishedforTheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors6382CoachfordWayMississaugaOntarioL5N3V8DougElseyP.EngExecutiveDirectorPhone905542-7410Fax905567-6703delseycadc.cawww.cadc.caPrintedbyMatrixGroupPublishingInc.309YouvilleStreetWinnipegMBR2H2S9Toll-free866999-1299Toll-freefax866244-2544salesmatrixgroupinc.netwww.matrixgroupinc.netPresidentCEOJackAndressChiefOperatingOfficerJessicaPotterjpottermatrixgroupinc.netPublishersJoeStrazzulloPeterSchulzEditor-in-ChiefShannonSavoryssavorymatrixgroupinc.netEditorAlexandraWalldawalldmatrixgroupinc.netFinanceAdministrationShoshanaWeinbergPatAndressNathanRedekopLloydWeinbergaccountingmatrixgroupinc.netDirectorofMarketingCirculationShoshanaWeinbergSalesManagerNeilGottfredTeamLeaderColleenBellMatrixGroupPublishingInc.AccountExecutivesBonniePetrovskyBrianMacIntyreCatharineMotleyChristopherSmithCrystalBurkeDavidRoddieDeclanODonovanFrankKenyeresFrankMcLeanJeffCashJimHamiltonJohnPriceJumanaWahoushMatthewKeenanMatthewPaxtonMilesMeagherRickKuzieRobertAllanRobertChoiStephenGaebelAdvertisingDesignJamesRobinsonLayoutDesignKaytiTaylor2013MatrixGroupPublishingInc.Allrightsreserved.Contentsmaynotbereproducedbyanymeansinwholeorinpartwithoutthepriorwrittenpermissionofthepublisher.TheopinionsexpressedinthispublicationarenotnecessarilythoseofMatrixGroupPublishingInc.PrintedinCanada.contentsUpFront6AMessagefromthePresidentoftheCADC7NotesfromtheExecutiveDirectoroftheCADC8WhyYouShouldBeaPartoftheCADC9BecomeaMemberontheCover12TheSnowMustGoOnWinterDivinginCanadaFeatUreStorieS18UsingSonarsforUnmannedDivingInspectionsPartII23ItsAllintheDetailsProperDataStorageProjectDocumentation26ImagesofInnovationnewS28DiversToolboxLookBeforeYouLeapHazardIdentificationandRiskAssessment31DiversSafetyCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementHealthSafetyCommittee32CADCMembershipListings201334BuysGudDivinginthewinterinCanadaisuniquetoourgeographicallocationhowevertherearedifferencesacrossourcountry.Wesatdownwithdivingcontractorsfromdifferentregionstolearnmoreaboutwinteroperationsdivinginiceslushandfrigidwatersandthechallengesthatcomewithdivinginwinterconditions.ThecoverofthiseditionofCADCMagazinefeaturesapolicejointforceicediveexercise.PhotobyDougElseywww.DougElsey.com.
6www.cadc.caFallWinter2013AsIsoakupthelastbitsofsummerandthinkofwhatistocometheideaoftrundlingofftoawarmerplaceduringthewinterbeginstoappealmoreeveryday.Itellmyselftostopwhining.Weliveinwhatisprobablythebestcountryontheplanet.SowhatifwehaveafewcrookedsenatorsItbeatshavingacrookedgovernmentdoesntitInpreparationforwinterourfearlessleaderDougElseyisgivingusinstructionsonhowtosurvivethewinter.CoupledwiththatisanarticlebyrenownedsonarexpertMarkAtherton.Intheconclusionofhistwo-partserieshetellsushowtoavoidthedangerofchillingwinterdivesbystickingoneofhismagicsonargizmosinthewaterthatwearetoldcandoamuchbetterinspectionjobthanaraggedy-asseddiver.OnamoreseriousnoteIattendedameetingofbehalfoftheCADCatWorkSafeBCforpurposesofdiscussingchangestothedivingregulations.Themeetingwaswellrepresentedbydifferentfactionsofthedivingindustryandeveryonehadtheopportunitytoargueeitherfororagainsttheproposedchanges.Inanyeventtheissuewasputonthebackburnerfornowandwillnodoubtberaisedagainatsomefuturedate.Safetyhasbeenandalwayswillbeamajorconcerninourindustry.Wemustallremembertousesafedivingpracticesandensurethateveryoneintheindustryisawareandwatchingforissuesthatcouldcauseharmtodivers.TheCADCDougElseyandourassociationmembershaveworkedhardtocreateastandardofexcellence.Itisimportanttoshareourexperiencessothatwecanlearnfromotherswhatshouldorshouldnotbedone.Letskeepourmindsandcommunicationlinesopenfornewsintheindustryandremembertoshare.ItisthroughyouourmembersthatwearesuccessfulinkeepingtheCADCintheforefrontoftodaysunderwatertechnology.OnbehalfoftheCADCIamwishingallmembersahappyandsafewinterseasonandaprosperousnewyear.AMessagefromthePresidentoftheCADCupfrontGlennCostelloCADCPresidentCratingastandardofexcllnc
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors7upfrontPullonyourwoollybearsandtightenyourtoquesNotesfromtheExecutiveDirectoroftheCADCDougElseyP.Eng.CADCExecutiveDirectorPhotoCreditD.GeddesAsthisgoestopressitisthemiddleofOctoberonaMondaymorningandtheheadlinesshowthatSouthernAlbertawashitbyablindingsnowstormovertheweekendtheleavesarentevenoffthetreesyetMarineoperationsthattookplaceonwateronFridayarenowthreateningtobecomeicebytheendofthedaywelcometofallwinterinCanadaOnethingwecancountoninCanadaiscoldweatherduringtheyearandtheiceandsnowthatcomewithit.OurfeaturearticlefocusesonwhatIwouldcallBigIceandtheBigChill.WeinterviewedmembersacrossCanadaaboutthedifferencesandsimilaritiesinwinteroperations.Fromworkinginbrineinthenear-shoreareasoftheSt.LawrenceRivertotheultra-coldinourArctictheonethingincommonisthediverisntgettinganycolderthanbaskinginabalmy32F0C.Thesurfacecrewsandgeartakethehit.ThejoysofcommercialdivinginCanadayahgottaloveitWecontinuewiththeconclusionofMarkAthertonsarticleontheuseofsonarinmarineoperationsonpage18.IfitblinksandwhirsbelowthewaterssurfaceMarksinsightandknowledgeonusingsonarforsearchingorinspectionsaresecond-to-none.ThearticleisonlythetipoftheicebergcheckouthisnewbookEchoesandImageswhichisnodoubtabouttobecomethego-tobookforallthingsscanningsonarvisitwww.echoesandimages.com.OnceaninspectionisdonebysonarormannedinspectionwhatdoyoudowiththeinformationBobClarkeP.Eng.ofASIGroupLtd.sortsoutwhattodowithandhowtopresenttheinformationtoyourclient.Fromworkinginbrine...totheultra-coldinourArctic...itisthesurfacecrewsandgearthattakethehit.ThejoysofcommercialdivinginCanadayahgottaloveitWorkingtogetherwithlabourmanagementandregulatorsondivingsafetyhasbeensomethingtheOntariodivingindustryhasdoneforyears.WelookattheinnerworkingsofOntariosCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementSafetyandHealthCommitteewhichfocusesonaworkablesafeindustry.IfaskedtoinspectamovingshipspropellerwhileitisunderwayisthefirstthingthatentersonesmindtoconsiderifariskassessmentisprudentThefactisinourindustryitisnotoptionalitisrequiredCADCdirectorDaveGeddesdiscussestheimportanceofproperhazardidentificationandriskassessment.TheCanadianUnderwatershowisbeingheldinTorontoApril6to82014.TheCADCAGMwilltakeplaceonApril6atthesamelocation.Plantobethereandtakeinthelatestpresentationsonourindustry.PullonyourwoollybearsandtightenyourtoquesCanadianeh.ItswinterKeepatighthoseanddivesafe.
8www.cadc.caFallWinter2013upfrontWhyYouShouldBeaPartoftheCADCCheckoutourmembersatwww.CADC.CAmembersPhotoCreditDougElseywww.DougElsey.comCADCisthegluethatbindsthedivingcommunityacrossCanadasaysDougElseyExecutiveDirectoroftheCADC.CADCwasformedin1982becauseregulatorsandgovernmentlegislatorsdidnotanddonotwanttotalktoindividualstheywanttotalktoorganizedgroupsrepresentingtheindustry.ThesafetystandardsthatgovernyouroperationstodayarearesultofpastCADCmembersdoingtheirjobingettingitrightsothatwehaveasafeandworkableindustrytoday.SafetyaccordingtoElseyisoneofthemostimportantissuesinanindustrythatcanbebothdangerousandphysicallydemanding.TheCADCactsasaunifyingbodyabletocommunicateeffectivelyacrossCanadaandbeyond.TheCADCactsawatchdogfortheindustryandkeepsaconstanteyeonregulationsandstandards.BecauseoftheirdiligenceinmonitoringthesestandardsandregulationsforcommercialdivingacrossCanadatheindustryhasbecomeamuchsaferplace.AsamemberyouareaddingtothevoicethatistheCADCeffectivelyallowingtheindustrytobeheardespeciallywhenitcomestoloweringinsurancerates.SomeofthebenefitsCADCmembershipoffersareConstantcommunicationsonjobscomingupthatyoumaybeinterestedinbiddingon.ThisisdoneweeklyorbiweeklyaswesendouttenderinformationacrossCanada.Informationavailableonourwebsitewww.CADC.caandtheCADC-sponsoredwebsiteswww.UnderwaterINDUSTRY.comandUnderwaterJOB.com.TheJOBSwebsitewww.UnderwaterJOBS.comwhereyoucanpostjobsandlookforqualifiedpeople.Themembersmail-listserverthatallowsyoutoinstantlycontactALLofthememberswhenyouneedadvicegearpersonneletc.DivinginsurancesexclusivelyforCADCmembersbackedbyLloydsandbrokerswhoknowthedivingindustry.Reducedratesongearfromourassociatemembers.Thisverymagazinewitharticlesoncompaniesjobssafetyetc.tokeepyouinformed.NoteveryonecanjoinCADC.ThosememberswhoapplyhavetoagreeANDdemonstratethattheyoperateinasafeworkingenvironment.OnecannotjoinbysimplyfillingintheformyouhavetohaveademonstratedlevelofsafetyandcompetenceinoperationstoCSAStandards275.2OperationsandCSA275.4Competency.Formoreinformationpleasecheckoutourwebsiteatwww.cadc.caore-mailinfocadc.ca.Welookforwardtohearingfromyou
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors9
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors11
onthecoverCanadaisanimmensegeographically-diversecountrywherethetemperaturecanvarywildlyfromseasontoseasonandfromcoasttocoasttocoast.TheweatherissoimportantthatevenourCanadianidentityisseentobeintricatelyinterwovenwithourrelationshiptotheoutsideenvironmentparticularlyduringthewintertime.Foradivingcompanythatworksduringthelongwintermonthstheextremecoldisnotjustadiscomforttoovercomeitprovidesadditionalchallengestooperationsthatareconsideredstrenuousunderidealconditions.ManeuveringmovingiceinQuebecWhileitistruethatthewintersarecoldinQuebecitisthetransitionfromwintertoearlyspringthatwillcausethemostconcernfordiversinlabelleprovince.InourprovinceweconsiderthatwinterconditionsstartinOctoberwiththefreezingcoldhumidity.ButwaterconditionsareattheirworstinFebruaryandMarchbecauseoftheicemovementswhichareextremelydangerousfordivers.AlsothewaterlevelsriseinthespringbecomingmuddyandtheflowisatitsmostpowerfulsaysYvesBecottepresidentofMVCOcanInc.Toavoidthepotentialdangersofmovingiceadivermustremainalertofhissurroundingsandbeabletoevaluatethechangesinweathertoavoidbeingcaughtunawarebyerranticeflows.Icedeflectorsmayalsobeusedtohelpdiverttheiceoutoftheworkareaandaroundthevulnerablediver.WhenwediveinthePortofMontrealandhavesomebacked-upiceflowingdownweneedtotakespecialprecautionsandinstallicedeflectorsordiveintotunnelstoensurethesafetyofthediversfrombeingdraggedawaybyicesaysBecotte.Anicedeflectorcouldbeabackhoesuspendingaplateofsteeltoblocktheincomingiceandprotectthediver.Itcouldalsobeasimplepipethatwouldensurethatiftheiceweremovingitwouldnotbreaktheumbilicalandplacethediverinjeopardy.Marc-AndrDesypresidentandownerofExpertechMarineInc.alsostressesthatextraawarenessandpreparednessarethetwothingsthatwillhelpkeepadiversafeduringthewintermonthsadvicethatringstruenotonlyinQuebecwinterconditionsbutinallcolddivingregionsacrossthecountry.Andwhilethereisalwaysthepotentialfordisasterwhencoldwaterdivingitisbytakingtheseprecautionsthattheprofessionitselfisverysafefordiversregardlessoftheseason.WearevigilantwithourequipmentandtakeintoaccountthecoldanditsimpactonthestaffandonthemachinerysaysDesy.Asafetyplanisdrawnoutandeachteamplayerhashistaskstoperform.Everyonehastodotheirpartinmaintainingasafeandcomfortabledivingenvironment.ByPaulAdairWinterDivinginCanadaTheSnowMustAwarenessandpreparednesshelpkeepdiverssafewhilecoldweatherdiving.PrecautionswithequipmentandmachinerylikeExpertechMarinesset-upbelowkeeptheprofessionalssafeineveryseason.12www.cadc.caFallWinter2013
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors13InordertofurtherprotectthediverfromtheelementstheprovinceofQuebecontherecommendationoftheCommissiondelaSantetdelaScuritduTravailCSSThastakentheadditionalstepoflegislatingthemandatoryuseofhotwatersuitswhileconductingextremecoldwaterdivingoperationswithintheprovince.Whenthethermometerdropstosub-zerotemperaturesitisoftenthediverinthewaterwhohastheenviablejob.OntheGreatLakesinthedeadofwinteritisthecrewleftontheicewhoaremostaffectedbythecold.AsfarasthedivergoesheslaughingsaysGordHaychiefdivinginstructoroftheCanadianWorkingDiversInstitute.Inthewateritsabovefreezingthereisnowindchillandmostlikelyheiswearinglongunderwearifnotthatthanahotwatersuit.Theguysontheicewhoareholdingthehosearetheonesthatreallyfeelit.Butweareatoughindustryandwedontputupwithalotofwhining.Thefactissometimesyourecold.Notonlydoesthecrewsufferthefreezingconditionsonthesurfacethecoldalsotakesatollontheequipmentusedtosupportthediverslowingthepaceofthedivingoperations.Onceyougetunder-20IwouldsaythatyouaredoingabouthalftheworkyouwouldnormallydoinwarmertemperaturessaysHay.Thereisjustafairbitmoretodoandalotmorepreparationtoconsiderwhendivinginthecold.Ittakesalotlongertogettheequipmentgoingsometimestakinguptothreehoursbeforeeverythingisupandrunning.Youwillgoouttostartthecompressoranditwontevenwanttoturnoverunlessyoukeepitconstantlypluggedin.AsidefromthecommoncomplicationsthatarisewhenworkingunderfreezingconditionsthereareGoOnIntheextremecoldthecrewsuffersfreezingconditionsonthesurfaceandthecoldtakesatollontheequipmentusedtosupportthediverslowingthepaceofdivingoperations.PhotoprovidedbyExpertechMarine.AnO.D.S.MarineLtd.diverpreparingforcoldweatherdiving.
somebenefitstooperatinginthewintersuchasbetteraccesstoremotelocationsandeasierdeliveryofmaterials.IfwecanwewillactuallyleavesomejobsuntilthewintersetsinsaysHay.Whenwelaypipelinesinthewinteryoucanjustsetthepipeacrosstheice.Youdonthavetoworryaboutgettingbargesinorbeconcernedaboutwindydays.Infactforsomeofthejobswedowecantevengetintothesiteuntilitfreezesbecauseoftheneedforiceroadsitsnotlikeyoucanflyinabunchofeight-inchpipe.WhistlingwindsontheprairiesWinterdivingincentralCanadaisforthemostpartthesameasdivinginanyoftheothercoldwaterconditionsacrossthenationatleastbelowthesurface.Ontheicehoweverthebarrensurroundinglandscapeabovethetree-lineprovidesanumberofissuesfordivingcrews.AtsomeoftheremotesitesyouareupagainstmanyofthesamethingsasinotherareasexceptthatitmightbecoldersaysGarthHiebertpresidentofDominionDivers.Thewindisprettymuchunimpededforthousandsofmilesastherearentanytreestospeakof.Onacoldwind-sweptstretchoflakewithverylittlesnowinsulationyouresometimesforcedtocuticeasthickasfivefeetjusttogetdownatthewater.Goingintotheriversoftheprairiescanbedemandingonthediverevenatthebestoftimes.Inthesummerthewatertendstobecloggedwithsiltandsedimentalmostcompletelyabsorbingthelightfromabove.Itsnotmuchbetterinthewinterwhenthevisibilityincreasesslightlybecauseoficeallowingthedivertoseeacoupleofinchesinanydirection.Additionallythetemperatureofthewaterseemstodropasitmovespastthediversimulatingawind-chillbelowthesurface.Ifyouareworkinginshallowerdepthsandespeciallyinmovingwaterthewaterseemstobeabletogetsuper-chilledandcanactuallygetlowerthanitnormallywouldsaysHiebert.Youdefinitelytendtofeelthedifference.Youneedtokeepactivebecauseifyouarenotworkinghardyoureallydogetcolderfaster.Whenyoucombineextremelycoldweatherconditionswithquicklymovingwaterlikewhenitflowsoverthetopofadamicecanpropagateandformwhatiscalledfrazzleice.Thisfrazzleicethenclumpsintoballsofslushwhichcanposearealproblemforhydrogeneratingstationsbyblockingintakevalves.TheseslushballsthatformareverystickyandveryheavysaysHiebert.Sometimesitsmucheasiertogetintotheslushthangetoutofitjustbecauseofhowheavyitis.Youcanfindyourselfhavingtogothroughfromanywherebetweenfiveto10feetofthisstuff.Andbecausetheslushislighterthanthewaterittendstobesuspendedtowardthesurface.ItisreallymorelikedivingthroughaSlurpeethanopenwater.TrickytidesinBCSomemightsaythatBritishColumbiaisoftenlookeddownuponbyfellowCanadiansforhavingamildersomemightevensaynon-existentwinterwhencomparedtotherestofthecountry.WhileaveragetemperatureswillnotdroptotheextremelowsoftheirprovincialneighboursBCdoeshaveitsfairshareofcoldwinterconditions.TheverylargelakessuchastheOkanaganmayhavesomefreezingontheshorelinebutrarelytowardthemiddlesaysGlennCostellopresidentofVancouver-basedCanPacDiversInc.Itjusthardlyevergetscoldenoughtoputicecoveroverthewholelake.ButwhenyougetintonorthernBCorwithsmallerlakesthatsadifferentthingaltogetherandtheywillfreezeover.Alongthecoastdiverswillneedtocontendwithhighcurrentsroughseasandtidalforcesthatfluctuatewiththeseasons.Insomecasesthetidescancausethesurfacetoriseandfallupto15feetandcausesignificantproblemsfordiversthroughnarrowoutlets.InVancouverwegetfirstandsecondnarrowsandthetidewillrunuptosevenknotsthroughthemsaysCostello.Adiversimplycantworkinanythingpast1.5knots.Anythingabovethatandhewillbeholdingonbyhisfingernails.LikethemovingiceinQuebecadivercanbestprotecthimselffromthetidalinfluencesbybeingawareoftheconditionsinwhichheisdiving.BeingpreparedandknowledgeableonthecoverWhendivinginthecoldthereisalotmorepreparationanditcansometimestakehourslongertogetequipmentupandrunning.DivinginLakeErieinFebruary.PhotoprovidedbyASIGroupLtd.14www.cadc.caFallWinter2013PhotoprovidedbyExpertechMarine.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors15ofupcomingweathertrendsisofparamountimportancetothediverinordertokeepoutofharmsway.PlummetingtemperaturesintheremoteArcticOver40percentofCanadastotallandmassisconsideredtobepartoftheArctic.ItisbarrentundrathatcapturestheessenceoftheCanadianwinterharshcoldandunforgiving.Itisalsoanareathatisincreasinglyfrequentedbydivingcompaniesthatarehopingtoinvestinthevastuntappedpotentialofthearea.SomeofthemajoreconomicmotivatorsfordiversintheArcticshiprepairandshiphusbandryoffshoredrillingsupportandtheinstallationandmaintenanceofmunicipaldrinkingwaterandsewagetreatmentsystemsinextremelyremoteconditions.InsomeoftheselittlevillagesthereisjustnothingtheresaysBillStarkmarineoperationsmanageratNorthernUnderwaterSystemsArcticDiversCanadianDetwatering.TherearefewlightsmaybeanadministratorandusuallyamemberoftheRCMP.Butotherthatthereisreallynothingupthereforsupport.ThislackoflogisticalsupportcreatesanumberofproblemsforadiverinthehighArctic.Somethingtakenforgrantedintheurbansouthsuchasobtainingmedicalassistanceincaseofemergencyishardertocomebyinthenorthandunfortunatelyhelpisnotalwaysjustaphonecallaway.Anytimethatadiveristhatmuchfurtherawayitcanchangeajobfromasimpletwo-daythingintoacomplexMovingicecanbedangerous.Diversmustevaluatethechangesinweathertoavoidbeingcaughtunawarebyerranticeflows.PhotoprovidedbyMVCOcan.SlushballswhicharelighterthanthewatertendtobesuspendedtowardthesurfaceandcanmakeitseemmorelikedivingthroughaSlurpeethanopenwater.PhotoprovidedbyExpertechMarine.
two-weekthingandthatsjustthewayitissaysStark.ItsnotuncommonintheArcticfordaystopasswherecommercialflightsjustdonthappen.AnditsextremelycommonintheArctictohaveweatherconditionsthatwontallowahelicoptertotakeoff.Soanymedicalissuethatmayarisethroughdivingiscompoundedbytheremoteness.Fortunatelywehavenothadanyincidentstodate.Additionallytheisolationoftheregioncanresultinmechanicaldeficiencieswhenitcomestomakingrepairsonequipmentthatwillinevitablyfailduetotheextremecold.Becauseofthisitwouldbewiseforadivertobecomefamiliarwiththelocalsinthecommunityinwhichheoperates.ItellmyguystomakefriendswiththemechanicattheairstripandhellbeyourbestsourceforpartssaysStark.Ifthereisadoctorinthecommunitymakehimawareofyouandreasonablyawareofwhatyouaredoinguptheresothatheisnotsurprisedwhensomebodygetsdraggedinwithamedicalproblemrelatedtodiving.Beingthatfarnorthtemperaturesplummetandthenightsarelong.Thiswillcreateexcruciatingultra-coldconditionsfordivingcrews.Becauseofthiscoldalmostalloftheequipmentneedstobeshroudedorkeptindoorstoremainfunctional.Wevehadcrewsworkingat-60andyoujustcantgetalotdonebecausetheequipmentdoesntwanttoworkwhenitsthatcoldsaysStark.Youhavelessthanthreehoursofdaylightduringthewintersoyoufindyourselfworkingoffofheadlightsandlightstandardsmoreoftenthannot.Everythingisdrivenbytheconditionsupthere.Undertheicepackofupto30feetofpermanenticetheconditionsareforthemostpartexcellentwithavisibilityofupto200to300feetandwithgenerallynegligibletidalforces.IronicallyhoweverthewateroftheArcticOceanisntallthatmuchcolderwhencomparedtotherestofthecountryfallingtoapproximately-2.ItreallydoesntseemtomatterawholehellofalotwhetheritissaltwaterorfreshwateritwillstilltakethewarmthoutofyouthesamewaysaysStark.Waterisacaloricsinktransferringheat25timesfasterthanair.Waterat-2onyourskinfeelsjustlikegettingburned.Ifyouweretotakeyourgloveoffinthatkindofwateratthattemperatureyouwillhaveamatterofsecondsbeforeyouvebasicallygotauselesslumpofwoodonyourwrist.BattlingbrineacrossCanadaThefinalcoldwaterconditionthatwillposeachallengetodiversisnotuniquetoanyoneregionofCanada.Brineconditionscanbefoundacrossthecountryandarelocatedwherethereissimplyahighersalinitytothewaterwhetheritisinanoceanicorindustrialsetting.Thebrineitselfisdenseandhasahighspecificgravitymakingitmoredifficulttosubmerge.Alsothehigherconcentrationofcalciumchloridefoundinbrineallowsittodropwellbelow0onthecoverWhenitcomestomovingiceadiversbestprotectionfromtidalinfluencesisbeingawareoftheconditionsinwhichheisdiving.16www.cadc.caFallWinter2013PhotoprovidedbyCanadianWorkingDiversInstitute.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors17withoutfreezingovertheprinciplebeingsimilartotheuseofsaltonthehighwaywheretheroadscanappearwetat-20.Theambienttemperatureofasuper-saturatedindustrialbrinepondcanfallaslowas-12considerablylowerthaneitherfreshorsaltwatertemperatures.Evenwiththebestsuitsintheworldadiverwillstarttofeelthechillwithin20minuteswherenormallythebestsuitsshouldprovideprotectionforhours.WedoveintoabrinepondtwowintersagoatapotashmineinSaskatchewansaysHiebert.Themineusedwatertogetthepotashoutoftheclayandthatwaterwasasuper-concentratedbrine.Itgotveryverycoldgettingwellbelowzerowithoutfreezingover.Wehadtocomeoutandhaveatruckofhotwaterheatthediverinatubinbetweendivesjusttogetourbodiesbacktonormal.Itwasamiserablecold.AnO.D.S.MarineLtd.diverbravesice-coldwatertogetthejobdone.
18www.cadc.caFallWinter2013featureActivesonarisadevicethattransmitsacousticenergyintothewatercolumnandmeasurestheelapsedtimeoftheechoedreturns.Themostcommonsonarsystemsusedtoaugmentdiverinspectionsincludeechosounderalsocalledadepthfinderorfathometerside-scansonarandscanningsonaralsocalledmechanicallyscannedorradialsonarwithimagingandorprofilingcapability.Eachsystemhasitsapplicationstrengthsandinherentlimitations.Theechosounderthesimplestofsystemsisalmostexclusivelyusedtodeterminewaterdepth.Thesounderstransducerthesystemcomponentthattransmitsandreceivestheacousticenergyisalignedsotheacousticpulseprojectstowardtheseabed.Withinthesonarelectronicsisaclockthatmeasuresthetimefromtransmittoreceivingtheechoedreturn.Toderivedistancetheclockedtimeismultipliedbyanin-waterspeedofsoundapproximately1500m4921persecondthisgivesthetotalortwo-waydistancethepulsetravels.Sincethewaterdepthisofinterestthetwo-waydistanceishalvedandgraphicallypresenteddisplayedasanumericvalue.Theaccuracyofthedataisafunctionofthetransducerbeamangletheseabedslopeandortransducerpitchrollandapplyingthecorrectin-waterspeedofsoundusedtocalculatedistance.Themaximumrangeofanechosounderoranysonarisafunctionofitsfrequency.Thestrengthofthesystemissimplicityofoperationandeaseofdatainterpretation.Whenechosounderdataistime-taggedrecordedwithaccuratepositionandpitchandrollinformationhighlyaccuratetwo-andthree-dimensionalplotsandbottomdepthcontourscanbegenerated.Theweaknessofthissystemisitslimitedcoverageandbeingabletopositionthevessel-mountedtransduceraboveascourholeorpointofinterestespeciallyinhighcurrentorareaswithlimitedvesselaccess.side-canSide-scansubseaelectronicsareoftenmountedinahydrodynamically-shapedtowedinstrumentcalledatowfishthathastransducersoneithersideofitslongaxis.Thesoundenergytransmitsviathetransducersperpendiculartothetowdirection.Whensoundenergycollideswithtargetsinitspaththeseabedsomeisreflectedbacktothesonarwhereitisdetectedandprocessed.Theresultisaplain-viewrecordofthebottomwiththeimagebuiltbynarrowacousticpulsesscrollingsimilarlytotheline-by-lineimagescrollingfromaprinter.Side-scanisanunbeatablewideareasearchandseabed-mappingtool.Itsresolutionisfunctionofitsfrequencyanditstransducershorizontalbeamanglehighfrequencyandnarrowerhorizontalbeamanglesimproverecordclarity.Typicallypulledviaacablecontainingelectricalconductorsbehindthesurveyvesselside-scanproducesthebestimagewhentowedatafixedspeedinastraightlineandatadeterminedaltitudeabovebottomrangedependant.Whencompletingaside-scansearchdeployamarkerbuoywhenatargetofinterestappearsonthedisplay.Thisisfollowedbyasecondsearchlinerunonareciprocalheadingandreversedalignment.Whenthetargetreappearsdeployasecondmarkerbuoy.Assumingthetowcablelengthandshipsspeedarethesameonbothsearchlinesthetargetisclosetomidpointbetweenthetwomarkersandoffsetfromthevesselcoursebytheperpendicularmeasureddistanceofthetargetfromthetowfish.Alternativelytheoperatorcanelectronicallymarkatargetusinganintegratedsonarchartplotterwhenthetowfishpositionanditsheadingareknown.Measurementandgeographicaccuracybetweentwoside-scantargetsisafunctionofknowingthetowfishpositionthatisontheendofacablebehindthevesseltowfishheadingandapplyingthecorrectsoundspeed.Mostside-scansystemsoftwareincludesaslant-rangecorrectionfunctionwhichworkswhentheseabedisflat.Itdoesnotscaletheimagecorrectlyonaslopedbottom.Thestrengthsofside-scanaretheimageclarityandsurveycoveragespeed.Withsingle-beamside-scanwhereasingleIntheSpring2013editionofCADCMagazineweranthefirstpartofthistwo-partseriesonsonarindivinginspections.Readonfortheconclusiontothislookathowsonartechnologycanaffectdivingoperations.UsingSonarsforUnmaPartIIByMarkW.AthertonTypicalechosoundercoverageanddisplay.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors19pulseistransmittedandreceivedbeforethenextistransmittedthetowspeedistypicallybetweenthreeandfiveknots1.54-2.57msec.Thereareoperationallimitationstousingside-scan.Anyinstabilityofthetowfishoftenduetovesselpitchandyawmovementtransmitteddownthetowcabledegradestheimage.Alsotheneedtopositionthetowfishclosetotheseabedenhancestheriskoflosingtheinstrumentinareasofdramaticallychangingslopesorthepresenceofmid-waterlinesoranchorcables.Itisoftendifficulttoobtaincompletecoverageadjacenttostructuresorwhenvesselsteerageoralignmentarerestricted.Althoughsomeoperatorshavebracket-mountedtheside-scantowfishtovisualizeunderwaterstructurestheneedtomaintainastraightlineandsurveyatafixedspeedlimitsthistoolformostbridgepierandothersubstructuralinspections.Side-scanisnotthetooltopositiondiversonatargetinrealtime.Towingside-scanandtryingtodirectadivertoatargetisbothineffectiveandpotentiallydangerous.scanningonarScanningsonaroperatesmuchthesameasside-scanbutdoessofromafixedposition.Thesonarheadproducesanacousticpulsethattravelsthroughthewatercolumnandechoedreturnsareoftenprocessedandpresentedinapolarplotresemblingaradarscreen.Aftereachpingamotorinthesonarheadturnsthetransducerandthepingprocessrepeats.Thekeytocollectinggreatscanningsonardataisheadstability.Keepingthesonarinafixedpositionforthetimeneededtocollectthescanproducestheclearestimages.Dependingontheselectedrangethiscantakeafewsecondstoaminuteormorerangeandresolutiondependant.Typicallydeployedonaremotelyoperatedvehicleormountedinatripodscanningsonarimageclaritylikeitsside-scancounterpartisheavilyinfluencedbythetransducerbeamangleandsonarheadstability.Uniquetoscanningsonarisitsmultiplemodesofoperation.Althoughmodelandmanufacturerspecificscanningsonarsoftwaremayincludeside-scanandechosounderfunctionalityanddualtransducermodelsthatallowmultiplefrequenciesandorimagingandprofilingcapabilitywithasinglehead.Becausesonaroperatesinaradialpatternfromafixedpositiontheoperatorcandeploytheheadinanyorientationtomatchtheunderwaterstructurealignment.Italsoallowsvisualizationofmostsubstructuralelementsaslongastheheadremainsstable.Deployingequipmentunderwateriswherecommercialdivingcompaniesexceloverothersonarusers.nedDivingInspectionsSide-scansonarbeamcoverage.A900kHzside-scansonarimageoftheYankeeshipwreck.Verticalvisualizationofagaswellblowout.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors21featureAsignificantcomponentofthedivingindustryisriggingdesigningadeploymentsystemforaninstrumentweighingafewkilogramstoremainstableistypicallyanon-issue.Scanningsonaristhesystemforpositioningadiverinrealtime.Deployingscanningsonarletstheteamidentifytargetsandpotentialhazardsbeforethediverdescends.Oncethediverisonbottomtheoperatorscanstheareaandguidesthedivertotargetsofinterest.Recordingthesonardataverifiestargetinvestigationandareacoverageandprovidesimagesofthesubstructuralelementsandsurroundingseabed.Submittedwiththediverreporttheseimagesestablishanundisputablerecordofthesubstructureconditionduringthesurvey.MonitoringthedivesitewithscanningsonarFittingscanningsonarwithaconicalbeamtransducergivesechosoundprofilingcapabilitywiththeaddedadvantageofscanningthrough360.Unlikeaconventionalsounderthatmustbemovedtoobtainadditionalcoveragethescanningsonarmotorturnstheconicaltransducerthroughthearcofprofilecoverageinterest.Thisopensupapplicationsforscourholeunderdockintakeoutfalldredgeandotherprofileinspectionprojects.Beamanglesapplyingthecorrectspeedofsoundconstantandtargettosonargeometryinfluencescanningsonaraccuracyjustlikeitsside-scanandechosoundercounterparts.Thestrengthofscanningsonaritsmultimodecapabilitywhilegeneratingimagesfromafixedpositionisalsooneofitslimitations.Anymovementtotheheadduringdatacollectiondegradesimagequality.Thefactitispositionedstationarytoobtaintheclearestimagesalsolimitsthespeedofdatacollection.SoitbegsthequestionwhatifanysonarservicesdotodayscommercialdivingcompaniesneedtoofferandwhatfinancialcommitmentdoesittaketoprovidethatcapabilityThereisnooneanswertothesonarservicesorinventoryneededbyacommercialdivingcompany.Themarketpotentialandcompetitiondictatethis.Andbeforemakingthesonarinvestmentunderstandthatgreatsonardatacomesfromtrainingandsystemfamiliarizationthebestoperatorsinthesonarbusinesshavemadethesecommitments.Timeshavechangedsincethat1984confrontationwiththecrustycommercialdiverandhisattitudethatsonarwastheretoreplacehisjob.Theneedtogetadivertotheunderwaterworksiteisntbeingalleviatedusingtechnologytomakediverinterventionsaferandmoreefficientistheindustrysdirection.Sonarispartofthatprocess.MarkAthertonisSpecialProjectsManageratKongsbergMesotechLtd.SegmentsofthisarticlearemodifiedexcerptsfromEchoesandImagesTheEncyclopediaofSide-ScanandScanningSonarOperationsbyMarkW.AthertonandanarticlecoauthoredbyMarkW.AthertonandBrianAbbottwhichwasoriginallypublishedinBridgeDesignandEngineeringMagazineissue45.Scanningsonarprofilesdataofaverticalrockshaftwithpreciseshaftdiametermeasurementstodesignalinerandpreventrockfromcalvingandpassingthroughahydroelectricturbine.Deployingthescanningsonarinacageandcollectinghorizontalprofilesatpredeterminedelevationsprovidedthedatasettocompletetheshaftlinerdesign.Scanningsonarimagingbeamcoverage.Augmentingdiverinspectionwithsonarimageryvirtuallyeliminatestheissueencounteredintheseawallinspectionanddiscoveryoftheoutfall.
22www.cadc.caFallWinter2013
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors23featureOncedatastartscominginfromadivinginspectionhowyoustoreitsortitandpresentittotheclientiscrucial.Learnmoreondatamanagementthebesttechniquestheequipmentyoushouldbeusingandtheimportanceofprojectdocumentation.Datamanagementasitrelatestoinspectionprojectsstartswithknowingwhythedataisbeingcollectedinthefirstplaceandisfollowedbywhatisbeingcollected.Thishelpsidentifywhichtechniquesandequipmentarebestsuitedforthework.Differenttechniquesandequipmenthavedifferentformatsfordocumentingfindingsbeitthroughtheuseofwrittennotesloggednumbersphotographsimagesandvideoorstreamsofrecordeddigitalinformationthathavetobecorrelatedinameaningfulwaysotheycontainandpresentusefulinformationtotheclientnowandinthefuture.Datetimelocationdescriptionthosearethebasiccomponentsthatneedtobedocumentedalongwitheveryobservationphotographorsensorreading.Usuallyalocalcoordinateorreferencesystemisusedasthecommonthreadtocorrelatetheinformationandpresentitusingwrittendescriptionsimagestablesandgraphsstronglyrecommendedovertablesofnumbers.Ifalocalcoordinateorreferencesystemdoesntexistestablishoneanddocumentitaspartofthereportpriortocommencingtheinspectionusingapermanentlocationfortheoriginorzerostartingpoint.Whenloggingdatastartwiththerelativepositionfollowedbytheobservationsothatitsnotforgottenintheprocessandestablishastandardmethodofreporting.Itisusefultorecordtimeaspartofthedataentryagainbeforethenarrativeportionisentered.Thismayseemredundantbutwhenmorethanonetechniqueisusedtimeistheeasiestmeansoftyinginformationtogether.Forexamplemostvideosystemsanddigitalcamerasprovideatleastthedateandtimeasavideooverlaywhichcandirectlycorrelatetothewrittenobservationforthatarea.Alsoifworkisbeingconductedfromdifferentlocationstheonlycommonmarkerforeventswillbetime.Inthisdigitalagethereisnothingwrongwithhand-writtennotesenteredonproperlyorganizedforms.Someclientsrequirethisformatusinginkonnumberedpagesmuchlikediverlogbookssothattheinformationtakenon-siteformsapermanentrecord.Iftherearealterationsorerrorsasingle-linestrikeoutwithsignaturefollowedbyasubsequententrycanProperDataStorageProjectDocumentationInthisdigitalagethereisnothingwrongwithhand-writtennotesenteredonproperlyorganizedforms.ItsAllintheDetailsByBobClarke
24www.cadc.caFallWinter2013featurebeused.Ihaveknowninspectionstobetranscribedfromarecordingmadethroughouttheinspection.Thismayseemtobeconvenientfortheinspectioncrewbutalsoposestoomanychancesforerrorsmissedinformationandmisunderstandingsduringthetranscriptionprocess.Alsothereisnothingtopresenttotheclientuponcompletionoftheinspectionandinmyexperienceclientsgenerallywantthereportalmostimmediately.Whenmoresensorsarebeingusedonagivenprojectdigitaldataentryandmanagementisabouttheonlywaytohandlealloftheinputsandstillmovetheinspectionalongatareasonablerate.Wherethiscanbeautomatedsomuchthebetterbuthumaninterfaceisalwaysneededforqualitycontrolandtoadjustoraltertheinspectiontocaptureanomaliesorprovidemoredetailwhenwarranted.Agoodstartingplaceisasimplespreadsheetorwordprocessingprogramthatusesatemplatefordataentry.Asmentionedautomationisgreatandtheinternetisfullofusefulroutinesthatcanbeusedtoautomatetimestampsorloggingofserialdatainputsintospreadsheetsorwordprocessingdocuments.Templatesareverysimpletosetupwithrowsandcolumnsforspecificdataentryintoatableandtheygiveaprofessionalappearancethroughtheuseofcompanylogosfreezethetoptitlerowsandnecessarycolumnssoyoudontlosetrackofwhichcolumntousefordataentry.Typingintheobservationnotescertainlykeepsthetextlegibleandthespellcheckfunctionalityinmostwordprocessingandspreadsheetprogramshelpstheinspectorgenerateapresentablereportalmostimmediately.Whenthedataneedstobesortedorfilteredaccordingtomultiplecriteriasuchasthelevelofdefectlocationortypeofdefectitmaybetimetotakethenextsteptoanactualdatabaseprogram.Whiletherearespecializeddatabasesystemsthataregearedfortheoffshoreindustryandbridgeinventoriestheexpenseofthesesystemsandthetechnicalsavvyneededtoproperlyusethesesystemsisonlywarrantedbythosecompaniesspecializinginthoseservices.Usingoff-the-shelfgenericdatabasesoftwareformscanbereadilydevelopedtoautomaticallyenterrepetitivedatalogfilenamesofphotographsperforminteractivefunctionswithexternalsensorsusingprogrammedgraphicalbuttonsandtocheckforcompletedataentrypriortomovingontothenextblankrecord.AtruedatabasetiestogethermultipletablesofinformationthatDatetimelocationdescriptionthosearethebasiccomponentsthatneedtobedocumentedalongwitheveryobservationphotographorsensorreading.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors25haveacommonlinkbetweenthem.Somesensorsanddigitalvideostreamsgeneratethesetablesautomaticallywithoutinterventionbytheoperatorusingsoftwarethatusesacommonthreadwiththeothertableshereswherethetimestampreallycomesintoitsown.Ifthedataisbeingcollectedusingonecomputerthenthattimestampcanoriginatewiththatcomputersclockandwillbeconsistentthroughoutallofthetablesofdata.WheremorethanonecomputerisbeinguseditisbesttouseautilitythatkeepstheclockssynchronizedoruseanexternalGPStimingsignaltobothsystemsifnotpersonalexperiencehasmademepainfullyawarethatclockswilldriftapartandmakedatacorrelationverydifficult.Oncethedatahasbeencollectedprocessedanddeliveredtotheclientalwayskeepacopyofthatfinalreportforyourownrecordsalongwithacopyoftherawdata.Theclientmaynothaveagoodsysteminplaceforarchivingtheirowndataanditisnotuncommontobeaskedforreplacementsseveralyearslater.Againusingtimedatesoftheprojectsisagoodwaytofilethem.Istronglysuggesttokeepanindexthatcanbeusedtocross-referencereportswithclientnamesconsistencyinclientnamesiskeyheresotheycanbeidentifiedlater.Wherethosecopiesarekeptisjustasimportant.IfounditinterestingthatwhenIlookeduppaperdocumentstorageoneofthetophitswastheCanadianConservationInstitutethereappearstobealotmoretodocumentstoragethanboxingitupandputtingitaside.Avoidusingthebasementforyourarchives.Basementsfloodareoftendamparepronetomildewandwillquicklyruinyourpaperandevendigitalrecords.Withtheadventofsecurecloud-basedoronlinestoragedigitalcopiesofinformationcanbereliablystoredandbackedupawayfromyouroffice.Isuggestdoingsomequickresearchusingyourfavouritesearchenginethenreviewyourpicksandselectaservicethatmatchesyourneeds.Withmostofmyworkbeinginspection-orientedoverthepast30yearstwopagesondatamanagementiscertainlyachallengeforwordmanagement.IhopeIhaveaddressedafewofthekeyelementstohelpmanageyourdatainitsacquisitionpreparationpresentationandarchiving.BobClarkeP.Eng.PMPisSr.OperationsManagerfortheMarineServicesDivisionatASIGroupLtd.
26www.cadc.caFallWinter2013featureImagesofInnovation1.AnMVCOcandiverduringinstallationofawaterintakeinthefreezingwatersofKangiqsualujjuagacommunitynorthofKuujjuagQC.PhotoprovidedbyMVCOcanInc.2.Adiverworkingonariverintakeliftstation.PhotoprovidedbyAdvanceDivingProjects.3.TheMVCOcanteamresurfacesthepilesofabridgeatPontDuplessisinTrois-RiviresQC.PhotoprovidedbyMVCOcanInc.4.FebruaryinLakeHuron.PhotoprovidedbyASIGroupLtd.5.AworkstationbasedontheBatiscanRiverinQuebecwhiledoinganunderwaterinspectionofabridgespile.PhotoprovidedbyExpertechMarineInc.6.LetsfaceitdivingisfunandwegetPAIDforitPhototakeninBCandprovidedbyCamcorDiveServicesInc.7.TheMVCOcanteamworkingonconstructionofanerosionprotectioninthePortofMontral.PhotoprovidedbyMVCOcanInc.Ltd.8.AdiverenteringwaterwhiledoinganunderwaterinspectionintheBatiscanRiverinQuebec.PhotoprovidedbyExpertechMarineInc.9.InstallationofthenewwaterintakeforthecityofVaudreuilQC.PhotoprovidedbyMVCOcanInc.10.AnO.D.S.marinedivecrewusinga300-toncranein-40CweathertopulliceblocksfordiverandmaterialaccessduringinstallationofconcretesedimentbarriersintheTrentRiverinTrentonON.PhotoprovidedbyO.D.S.MarineLtd.11.Astudentemergingfromatrainingtankoutsideduringthewinterafterbeingtrainedinusingahotwaterdivingsystem.PhotoprovidedbyInstitutemaritimeduQuebec.12.FishfarmdivingonthewestcoastofBCatitsfinestPhototakeninBCandprovidedbyCamcorDiveServicesInc.162410759128113
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors27
28www.cadc.caFallWinter2013newsAswestarttogatherthepaperworkforanewprojectoneofthefirstthingswehavetodevelopisourhazardidentificationandriskassessmentstrategy.TherequirementfordetailedriskmanagementandplanningistoprovideassurancetothoseinvolvedwiththeprojectthatallprojectelementsarereviewedwiththeintentofidentifyinghazardsandreducingtherisktoalevelalowaraoablypracticablALARP.Itshouldbeemphasizedthatnotonlyisthisusuallyarequirementoftheclientbutalsoalegalrequirement.InthisarticlewewilldiscussRiskManagementwithafocusonHazardIdentificationandRiskAssessmentHIRA.SimplyaHIRAisacarefulexaminationofwhatinyourworkcouldcauseharmtopeopleequipmentortheenvironmentandallowsyoutodetermineifyouhavetakenadequateprecautionstopreventharm.HAzARdAnythingwiththepotentialtocauseharm.RIskThelikelihoodchanceprobabilitythatharmwilloccurandthedegreeofimpact.COnTROLMeAsUReSomethingcontrolthatpreventsorreducesrisk.HazardIdentificationandRiskAssessmentHIRAisathree-stepprocesscarriedoutpriortocommencingtheproject.Theobjectiveistoidentifythehazardsassociatedwiththeprojectanddeveloporimplementcontrolsmitigationsandactionstoreducetheriskstoalevelaslowasreasonablypracticable.Itisimportanttoincludeallpartieswhoseactionsoromissionscouldaffectthehealthandsafetyofpersonsengagedintheprojecttheenvironmentthecontractorsorcompanysassetsandtheoperationalexecutionperformance.ItisessentialthatnecessarypersonnelareavailableforallphasesoftheriskassessmentthiscanincludepersonnelfromthefollowingOperationsinstallationsworksiteareamanagementandcontrolsystemstobeusedduringtheworkSubcontractorscommissioningpumpingrockdumpinggroutingsurveydredgingcranehaulagesecurityetc.Specialistsmarineaviationliftingetc.andThird-partyoperators.Step1oftheHIRAprocessisconductedinanofficeenvironment.Participantsincludemanagerssupervisorsandpersonnelwithresponsibilityintheprojectorportionsoftheproject.Thisprocesswilltakepartinadvanceofthecommencementofworkandwillidentifyrequiredchangestotheworkscopeortheimplementationofanymitigatingfactors.Inadditioneachtaskoftheworkplanwillbereviewedstep-by-steptoensureallriskshavebeenidentified.Thecontractorappointedtoprovidetheworkisresponsiblefortheriskassessment.Ifforsomereasonthecontractorischangedorreplacedtheriskassessmentprocessmustberepeated.Step2oftheHIRAprocessisperformedbypersonneldirectlyinvolvedinthesupervisionofthework.UsingtheStep1resultsasaguidelinetheStep2HIRAteamwillreviewtheresultsandbuilduponthem.ThisisanopportunityformoreoperationalinputtobeincludedintheHIRA.ByDaveGeddesDiversToolboxLookBeforeYouLeapHazardIdentificationandRiskAssessmentLookbeforeyouleapdevelopyourhazardidentificationandriskassessmentstrategyMobilizationTaskHazardConsequenceQuantifyRiskControlMeasureResidualRiskTrainingFamiliarizationUnfamiliarOHSregulations.Incompletetrainingfamiliarization.Unfamiliarworkscope.Unfamiliarpersonnel.Unfamiliarequipment.Injurytopersonnel.Damagetoequipment.Spilltoenvironment.3CMedCMProvidetrainingandfamiliarizationforallprojectpersonnel.CMRecordoftrainingandfamiliarizationforallprojectpersonnelisonrecord.CMSub-contractorscontinuityfamiliaritywithdivesiteandmobilizationprocess.CMToolboxtalk.2BLow134562
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors29Step3iscommonlyknownastheToolboxTalk.InthissessiontheHIRAwillbediscussedwithpersonnelwhoareactivelyinvolvedorperformingthework.TheToolboxTalkwillbeheldpriortothestartofwork.Allriskspertainingtotheworktobeaccomplishedduringtheshiftdayetc.willbediscussedandallcontrolmeasuresormitigationwillbereviewed.AtthispointImsuremanyofyouarethinkingOkaygreatMorepaperworkButwhatistheprotocolItsquitesimpleMostdivingcontractorsuseatabularformatfortheHIRAprocess.ThisworksheetcanbedevelopedquitesimplywiththefollowingtitlesTaskHazardConsequencePersonnelEquipmentortheEnvironmentQuantifyRiskControlMeasureCMorMitigationandResidualRisk.ThiscanthenbepopulatedduringtheStage1processorpartiallypopulatedinadvancebythedivingcontractortosavetime.Anotetothewisethisisbestdoneinadvancebythedivingcontractorotherwiseyouwillbewiththeownerclientandhisherrepsallday.Tocompletetheworksheetyouwillneedsomesortofbenchmarktoquantifyrisk.TherearemanyRiskMatrixformatsavailablethroughOccupationalHealthandSafetytradeorganizationsandorconstructionsafetyorganizations.Aworksheetandriskanalysismatrixmayevenbesuppliedbytheclient.ForthepurposeofthisarticlewewillusetheIMCAInternationalCodeofPracticeRiskMatrix.NowwecanbegintodeveloptheHIRAReferenceFigure1belowasyougothroughthebelowstepsstep1Identifythetask.step2Identifythehazard.step3Consequenceofthehazard.step4QuantifyriskusingoneoftheRiskMatrixsavailableorproprietaryproductsdeterminestherisk.InthiscaseweareusingtheIMCAMatrix.ThisdescribestheriskasPossible3withaquantifiedriskofCwhichrepresentsaModerateInjuryoroccurrencewhichisamediumrisk.step5TocontrolthisriskwearegoingtoapplyControlMeasuresormitigation.step6InapplyingtheControlMeasuresyouareabletoreducetherisktoanacceptablelevelwhichinthiscaseisanUnlikelyOccurrencewithlowrisk.Anyriskinthehighcategorymustbereducedtomediumorlowpriortotheactivitytakingplace.Thisprocessshouldcontinuethroughallaspectsoftheprojecttoensureallhazardsareidentifiedandcontrolled.ChangestothescopeofworkshouldbeexpectedandshouldbedealtwiththroughaformalizedManagementofChangeprocedure.Weprideourselvesonarecordofsafetydevelopedthroughtheconformancetostandardsandregulationsthatarehighlyregardedthroughoutthedivingindustry.Wecanonlyensurethiscontinuesbycompletingproperandthoroughhazardidentificationandanalysisandmostimportantlybyinvolvingthepersonnelwhoperformthework.DaveGeddesisaCADCDirectorandChairoftheCSAsubcommitteefortheCompetencyStandardforDivingOperationsClinicalChamberOperatorsandROVPersonnel.HeownsandoperatesD.W.GeddesAssociatesInc.aconsultingcompanyfordivingandhyperbaricoperations.Hecanbereachedatdwgeddessympatico.ca.ExcerptsofthisarticlearefromOGPDivingRecommendedPractice.Figure1HazaRDSEVERitYoUtCoMEPRobabilitYinJURYSPillPollUtionDaMaGEoRloSSoFPRoDUCtionVeryUkey1Ukey2Psse3lkey4Verylkey5VERysERIousDeathrmtipeerin-terminjrie100M3USD1millionMMHHHEsERIousDaawafrmwrkcaeinjrDAFWC100Ltr-100mUSD50000-1millionLMMHHDMoDERATERetrictedwrkcaeinjrRWC10-100LtrUSD10K-50KLLMMHCslIgHTMedicatreatmentcaeinjrMTC1-10LtrUSD
30www.cadc.caFallWinter2013
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors31newsDaveGallagherChairpersonoftheCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementHealthSafetyCommitteeisjustifiablyproudoftheachievementsoftheDivingTradeCommitteeinimprovinghealthandsafetyforthoseworkingintheOntariocommercialdivingindustry.Animportantfeatureofthecommitteeishowlabourandmanagementworktogetherwithgovernmenteducatorsandenforcementagenciestocometoaconsensusonimprovementsinhealthandsafetyforthecommercialdiverandtakingintoaccountthepracticalaspectsofthework.Thecommitteeisoneof40committeesintheInfrastructureHealthSafetyAssociationlabour-managementnetwork.ThedivingtradecommitteealsocomesundertheumbrellaoftheProvincialLabour-ManagementHealthSafetyCommitteewhichisaSection21AdvisoryCommitteetotheOntarioMinisterofLabour.ThepurposeoftheCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementHealthSafetyCommitteeistoworkforimprovementsinthehealthandsafetyofthoseworkinginthedivingtradewiththegoalofeliminatingallinjuriesandfatalitieswithinthetradeandmakingOntariothesafestjurisdictionforcommercialdiving.TheCommercialDivingTradeCommitteeismadeupof24committeddivingprofessionalsfromtheUnitedBrotherhoodofCarpentersJoinersofAmericarepresentingLabourandownersandmanagersofdivingcontractingcompaniesincludingGalconForandMarineConstructionLtd.ASIGroupLtd.DivingServicesSoderholmMaritimeServicesInc.DepartmentofNationalDefenceandDundeeEnergy.Non-votingmembersinvolvedinthedivingindustryincludetheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractorsD.W.GeddesAssociatesDefenceRDCanadaSenecaCollegeKingCampusCanadianWorkingDiversInstituteOntarioPowerGenerationOntarioProvincialPoliceUnderwaterSearchandRecoveryUnitandtheMinistryofLabour.TheCommercialDivingTradeCommitteehasbeenactiveinimprovinghealthandsafetyforcommercialdiversinOntario.ThiscommitteemeetsregularlyfourtimeseachyearattheIHSAHeadOfficeinMississaugatodiscusshealthandsafetyissuesaffectingthedivingtradeandtoconductformalbusiness.ThiscommitteeisalsoactivelyholdingworkinggroupmeetingsasneededtoworkondivingsafetydocumentsandpublicationsandtomakerecommendationsonanychangestotheOntarioRegulation629DivingOperations.TheMinistryofLabouracceptedmanyoftherecommendationsforlegislationchangethatwassubmittedinthepastbytheCommercialDivingTradeCommitteetoimprovehealthandsafetystandardsinthedivingindustry.SometopicsthatthedivingtradecommitteehasbeenworkingonincludethefollowingDeltaPHazardsPinDivingOperationsByGeorgeIaconoDiversSafetyCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementHealthSafetyCommitteeQualityofbreathingairExplosivesordinancedisposalDiverre-certificationandAcknowledgementofdivingasarecognizedtrade.MembersoftheCommercialDivingTradeCommitteeprovidedcommentaryandfeedbacktotheIHSAontheDiverSupervisorLogBookRF007whichwasreprintedandrebrandedasanIHSApublicationin2012.TheCommercialDivingTradeCommitteeworkedontrainingprocedurestoprepareforworkforthefederalgovernmentonretrievingunusedexplosives.ThecommitteeislobbyingtohavethehyperbaricchamberatTorontoGeneralHospitalstaffed24hoursperdayandduringoff-hourstoensurethehyperbaricchamberisavailableimmediatelyfortreatmentinadivingemergency.TheCommercialDivingTradeHealthSafetyCommitteehasmadegreatstridesasdemonstratedbytheaccomplishmentsthegrouphasundertakenin2012.ThecommitteecontinuestobeakeyingredientoftheIHSALabourManagementNetworkandisadrivingforcebehindthehealthandsafetybestinterestsofthesector.ToparticipateintheCommercialDivingTradeLabour-ManagementHealthandSafetyCommitteecontactGeorgeIaconoattheInfrastructureHealthSafetyAssociation800263-5024orvisitwww.ihsa.ca.GeorgeIaconoisCoordinatorStakeholderandHeadofPublicRelationsattheInfrastructureHealthandSafetyAssociation.TheCentreforHealthSafetyInnovation.CommitteemembersworkondivingsafetydocumentsandpublicationsandmakerecommendationsonanychangestotheOntarioRegulation629DivingOperations.PhotoCreditBothphotosbyDougElseyDougElsey.com
32www.cadc.caFallWinter2013newsAlBERTAAdvanceDivinPrjectDarrinMoenchCalgaryAB403612-3162advancedivinggmail.comAiedCmmerciaDiverltd.BradNiehausEdmontonAB780439-1889brad.niehausallieddivers.comAqaTechDivinserviceJohnDickauBlackfaldsAB403885-4590johndickaugmail.comNrthernunderwatersytemlPBillStarkEdmontonAB403650-0474wstarknusgroup.comPanDaktaDiveserviceJeffWilliamsExshawAB403678-7441pandakotagmail.comBRITIsHColuMBIAAdvancedsbeaserviceltd.MurrayMackaySidneyBC250656-1770murrayadvancedsubsea.comAseaEnterprieMarkMorganVancouverBC604980-9613officeall-sea.comAqa-lnCanadaltd.JohathanChappleSaanichtonBC902404-0759jchappleaqualung.comBCCeefDivinCoryBeaudrySidneyBC250726-5522camcordivingtelus.netCan-DiveCntrctinltd.MurrySpierVancouverBC604984-9131nrlnuytco.comCanadianCatgardStewartSimmsRichmondBC604803-9041stewart.simmsdfo-mpo.gc.caCanPacDiverInc.GlennCostelloVancouverBC604984-8383glenncanpacdivers.comCaribChictinDiverltd.AllisterThompsonVancouverBC250612-8827cariboodiversaol.comDivesafeInternatinaKellyKorolCampbellRiverBC250287-3837kellydivesafe.comDivinDynamicVernJohnsonKelownaBC250861-1848verndivingdynamics.comsbeaTechnyspeciaitJimEnglishLionsBayBC778280-5056jimenglishshaw.caFraerBrrardDivinltd.AaronHeathDeltaBC604940-9177fbdivinggmail.comoceanWrkIntCrp.DerekWhiteBurnabyBC604415-0088dwhiteoceanworks.comsmartsafesafetyHeathCntantltd.SteveDuffySurreyBCsmartsafetelus.netsthCatDivinltd.PatThompsonVictoriaBC250361-1556infosouthcoastdiving.comMANIToBADmininDiver2003ltd.GarthHiebertWinnipegMB8005994933ghiebertdominiondivers.caNEWBRuNsWICKAseaAtanticltd.KentGrassSt.JohnNB506648-3483kentatlantic-all-sea.comEatDiveltd.JohnMcFadzenIslandViewNB506459-3483eastdivenbnet.nb.cashipTshreDivinandEnineerinDaveLewisAmmonNB506389-3483shiptoshorenb.aibn.comNEWFouNDlANDlABRADoRAfngrpltd.StephanChafeSt.JohnsNL709576-6070schafeafonsogroup.comCrttyDivinserviceInc.AlCrottyStJohnsNL709782-8788crottydivingnf.aibn.comoceaneerinCanadaTimLawrenceMountPearlNL709570-7072tlawrenceoceaneering.comPr-DiveMarineserviceDaveSquiresSt.JohnsNL709368-8501davidsquiresprodive.casea-FrceDivinltd.BarryHynesMountPearlNL709753-2021barryseaforcediving.comNoVAsCoTIACnnrDivinserviceltd.NeilConnorsLakesideNS902876-7078neilconnorsdiving.comDmininDivinltd.ShawnMacPhailDartmouthNS902434-5120divingdominiondiving.comHihpintsafetyltd.JohnScottShubenacadieNS902576-7827jscotthighpoint-safety.comHnteysbAqaCntrctinMikeHuntleyKentvilleNS902678-9869sandandseasandandseadiveshop.caKnberMaritimeNickBurchillDartmouthNS902468-2268nick.burchillkongsberg.comRMIMarineltd.RobRitchyEasternPassageNS902463-6114robrmimarine.caoNTARIoAseagreatlakeRobertBoldtSt.CatharinesON905933-1667greatlakesall-sea.comAsIgrpltd.BlakeGouletSt.CatharinesON905641-0941gouletasi-group.comCanadianFrceDivinsafetyDNDCdr.LeanneCroweOttawaON613971-7680leanne.croweforces.gc.caCanadianWrkinDiverIntitteGordHayBuckhornON705657-2766infocanadianworkingdivers.comCanadianWrkpacesafetyBobLandryScarboroughON416931-6552rwlandrysympatico.caD.W.geddeAciateInc.DaveGeddesAuroraON905833-2085dwgeddessympatico.caDeepTechserviceltd.DougElseyMississaugaON905542-3223delseydeeptech.comDivinserviceBrianMcCodanPeterboroughON705742-5817bmcdivingservices.netDndeeEnerylPMikeWaldiePortColborneON905834-2963mwaldiedundee-energy.comgacnMarineltd.DaveGallagherTorontoON416255-9607galconbellnet.caHyperbaricCntantJimWilsonretiredNorthYorkON416225-1753wilsonj1sympatico.caKCPwerHeRepairMarcBlaisSmoothRockFallsON705338-2564kcpowerntl.sympatico.cao.D.s.Marineltd.JimFreethOttawaON613821-3988jimodsmarine.comontariPrvinciaPiceunderwatersearchRecveryunitRockyBolgerGravenhurstON705330-2529ronald.bolgerontario.caReimerHyperbaricfCanadaDaveReimerElmiraON519669-0220reimerhyperbaricsbellnet.casenecaCeeAaronGriffinKingCityON416491-5050aaron.griffinsenecacollege.casderhmMaritimeserviceInc.LeifSolderholmHamiltonON905529-1344lsoderholmsoderholmmaritime.comPRINCEEDWARDIslANDHandCeeStephanWhiteSummersidePE902652-2055stwhitehollandc.pe.caQuEBECAxsbInc.LucGarandRimouskiQC418731-0231luc.garandaxsub.comExpertechMarineInc.Marc-AndrDesyQuebecQC418694-7444madesyexpertechmarine.comInnvatinMaritimeNicolasParentRimouskiQC418725-3225nparentimar.caIntittemaritimedQebecSergeLavoieRimouskiQC418724-2822slavoieimq.qc.caMVCocanInc.HlneMarchildonTroisRiviresQC819377-2856yvesmvcocean.comsPgHydrInternatinaInc.YvesRicherSainte-JulieQC450922-3515richerspghydro.comuNITEDsTATEsCaDiveAllanPalmerHoustonTX713586-7361apalmercaldive.comDiverIntittefTechnyInc.JohnPaulJohnstonSeattleWA206783-5542jpjohnstondiversinstitute.comEpicDivinandMarineserviceWilliamBratkowskiBelleChaseLA504681-1200bbratkowskiepiccompanies.comCommittedtoSafetyPerformanceProfessionalismCADCMembershipListings2013TfindthwycanbecmeamemberftheCADCviitwww.CADC.ca.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors33sAFETyCADCMembersAsaconditionofmembershipeachandeverymemberoftheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractorscommitstoadherencetoCSADiveSafetyStandardsZ275.2DiveOperationsandZ275.4DiverCompetency.HiringresponsiblesafeandprofessionalunderwaterserviceprovidersoftheCADCisgoodbusiness.Foracompletelistofmembersgotosafety.Performance.Profeionalim.www.cadc.camembersPERFoRMANCEPRoFEssIoNAlIsMCommittedto
34www.cadc.caFallWinter2013buyersguideAuToNoMousuNDERWATERVEHIClEOceanServerTechnologyInc..............................16BuRlAPslINgBAgsQuikrete.......................................insidebackcoverCERTIFICATIoNDiverCertificationBoardofCanada......................6CIVIlANDDIVINgsERVICEsKCPowerhouseRepair.....................................17CoMMERCIAlDIVERTRAININgCanadianWorkingDiversInstitute......................22DiveSafeInternational........................................30HollandCollege...................................................30CoMMERCIAlDIVERTRAININgCENTERMinnesotaCommercialDiverTrainingCenter......27CoMMERCIAlDIVINgEQuIPMENTBay-TechRentals.........................insidefrontcoverCavidyne.............................................................11ConnorsDivingServicesLtd.................................3CoMMERCIAlDIVINgsuPPlIEsDiveCommercialInternationalInc.......................11CoRRosIoNPRoTECTIoNDenso..................................................................34DIVINgANDENgINEERINgShipToShoreDivingEngineeringLtd..............17DIVINgCoNTRACToRsBouchardBlanchetteMarineLtd......................33Can-DiveConstructionLtd..................................17CanpacDiversInc...............................................24DominionDiversLtd............................................20ExpertechMarine..................................................4MVCOcan.........................................................11NorthernUnderwaterSystemsCanadianDewatering........................................................15DIVINgEQuIPMENTMIlITARyANDPRoFEssIoNAlAqua-LungCanadaWhitesManufacturing........34DIVINgsCHoolDiversInstituteofTechnology.............................34DIVINgsERVICEsDivingServicesInc..............................................33SoderholmMaritimeServicesInc........................33EDuCATIoNTRAININgCDATechnicalInstituteFormerlyCommercialDivingAcademy...............................................11HoTWATERsysTEMsCustomDesignFabrication................................4HyDRAulICToolsANDATTACHMENTsAccudraulicsInc..................................................27IMAgINgsoNARTECHNologIEsMarineSonicTechnologyLtd.......insidebackcoverMARINEANDuNDERWATERsERVICEsASIGroupInc......................................................22MARINECoNsTRuCTIoNGalconMarineLtd...............................................30O.D.S.Marine......................................................30MARINEElECTRoNICsDeepSeaPowerLight.........................................8MooRINgFouNDATIoNssuBsEAIntermoor............................................................17oFFsHoREEQuIPMENTsAlEsANDRENTAlsUniqueSystemLLCUSA.....................................7RoPEMANuFACTuRINgNOVABRAID..........................................................3soNARsuNDERWATERCAMERAsANDTRACKINgsysTEMsKongsbergMaritimeLtd............outsidebackcoveruNDERWATERTHICKNEssgAugEsCygnusInstruments............................................25DntmitnrchancetadvertieinthenexteditinCa866999-1299.
TheCanadianAssociationofDivingContractors35